FixQuotes vs MyBuilder for rental maintenance
MyBuilder lets you post a job and field the responses yourself. FixQuotes writes the job up and returns comparable quotes where local supply supports it. The difference matters most when there's a tenant waiting.
- Published
- Reading time
- 8 min read
The short answer
- MyBuilder is a job-posting marketplace. You post the job, interested tradespeople get in touch, and you shortlist and compare the replies yourself.
- FixQuotes is a managed service. You send the job once; we write it up and return comparable quotes in one email where local supply supports it, free for landlords and agents.
- MyBuilder wins on choice and its established review/feedback system. FixQuotes wins on doing the write-up, the chasing and the comparing for you.
- Both use independent trades and neither carries out the work. With MyBuilder you manage the conversation; with FixQuotes we do.
FixQuotes vs MyBuilder at a glance
| FixQuotesManaged sourcing | MyBuilderJob marketplace | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost to landlord | Free. | Free to post a job. (Trades pay for leads/to make contact.) |
| How you get quotes | Send the job once; we brief it and return quotes to you. | Post the job; interested trades contact you, then you arrange quotes. |
| Are quotes comparable? | Yes. Every trade prices the same job, so the quotes are easy to put side by side. | Not by default — quotes arrive in each trade's own format; you normalise them. |
| Who manages the back-and-forth | We do — you receive a finished comparison. | You do — messaging, shortlisting and follow-up sit with you. |
| Reviews / feedback | Newer service; no fake reviews. | Established job-feedback and rating system. |
| Built for | Landlords, agents and property managers; compliance-aware briefs. | All homeowners; general home-improvement and trade jobs. |
| Best for | Busy landlords who want quotes they can put side by side without managing the thread. | Owners happy to vet replies and run the conversation themselves. |
Comparison reflects each service's published model as of May 2026. MyBuilder is a trademark of its respective owner; FixQuotes is independent and not affiliated with MyBuilder.
How MyBuilder works
MyBuilder is a marketplace where you post a job and tradespeople who are interested respond. You then look at their profiles and past job feedback, shortlist the ones you like, and invite them to quote. Tradespeople pay to be matched to or to contact you about a job.
It's a well-built model with a long-standing reputation system, and it works nicely for one-off home-improvement jobs where you have the time to read profiles, exchange a few messages, and choose.
Where it gets harder for landlords
Posting a job is the easy part. The work is what comes after: replying to interested trades, arranging access around a tenant, getting each one to quote, and then comparing quotes that don't line up — one includes parts, another is labour-only, a third hasn't mentioned the call-out fee.
Across a portfolio, or when a tenant is without heating and the clock is running, managing several separate conversations is exactly the friction landlords are trying to avoid.
What FixQuotes handles for you
With FixQuotes you describe the job once. We write the job up properly, share the same brief with relevant local trades for that job type, chase the responses, and send you the quotes side by side where supply supports it. You don't manage the thread — you just pick.
And because it's built for rented property, the brief already accounts for the compliance side: the right qualification (checked against the Gas Safe Register for gas, Part P schemes for fixed electrical), the right document (EICR, CP12, EPC) and the right scope for a tenanted home.
When MyBuilder is the better choice
If you have the time and you like being in control of the selection — reading profiles, messaging trades, choosing based on feedback — MyBuilder's marketplace is a strong, proven fit, particularly for larger one-off projects where you want to interview a few firms.
When FixQuotes is the better choice
FixQuotes fits when you'd rather not run the process: you manage multiple properties, you want comparable quotes against one brief, and you want the compliance angle handled. You send the job and we return the comparison where local supply supports it — free for landlords and agents.
Common questions
Is MyBuilder free for landlords?
Posting a job on MyBuilder is free for the person who needs the work done; tradespeople pay to be matched to or contact you about jobs. FixQuotes is also free for landlords and agents — contractors pay a referral fee only when they win the job.
What's the main difference between FixQuotes and MyBuilder?
Effort and comparability. On MyBuilder you post the job and manage the responses and comparison yourself. With FixQuotes we write the job up, source relevant trades and return comparable quotes where local supply supports it, so the decision is clearer.
Which is faster for an emergency like no heating?
FixQuotes flags emergencies (no heating, leaks, electrical faults) and prioritises them, returning quotes from available Gas Safe or qualified trades without you having to post, wait and chase. On a marketplace you're dependent on which trades happen to respond and how quickly.
Can I use both?
Yes. Some landlords post bigger refurbishment projects on a marketplace and use FixQuotes to get a comparable quote pack for routine and compliance jobs. There's no lock-in with FixQuotes.
Keep reading
- FixQuotes vs Checkatrade for landlords
- FixQuotes vs Rated People for landlords
- Checkatrade vs MyBuilder: which is better for landlords?
- 7 Checkatrade alternatives for UK landlords (2026)
- FixQuotes vs TrustATrader for landlord repairs
- FixQuotes vs Bark for landlord repairs
- FixQuotes vs Taskrabbit for landlord repairs
- FixQuotes vs Which Trusted Traders for landlord repairs
- FixQuotes vs TrustMark for landlord repairs
- FixQuotes vs Google for landlord repairs
- FixQuotes vs Yell for landlord repairs
- FixQuotes vs Houzz for landlord repairs
- How to vet a tradesperson
- Tenant has no heating: your duties
- Emergency boiler repair quotes
- Plumbing repair quotes
- Roof repair quotes
- End-of-tenancy refurbishment quotes